Posted by: Marianne | April 15, 2008

Choices

There have been a number of posts around the ’sexosphere’ recently about the issue of infidelity and adultery. Some of them have been a little judgmental. Others have been accused of glorifying it. And some have been purely exploratory in nature. It doesn’t really bother me to read the opinions of others on something that is clearly an issue for me on more than just an intellectual level. Every day, I come to terms with my choice to step outside of my marriage for sexual and emotional fulfillment. I deal with the fact that I’ve chosen not to tell my husband about that choice. How I come to terms with it, what my thought process is, my reasons, my justifications and rationalizations — none of that is really the business of anyone but me and him. I don’t choose to share my reasoning here, although I have told a few people some parts of it. One of the choices I’ve made along the way is to respect the abilities of others to make their own decisions for their own reasons, and to expect them to accord me the same respect and consideration. Generally speaking, I have found my plan to be entirely successful. I associate with people who understand that life is complex and that there are no one-size-fits-all solutions. Those people make me happy.

That’s my choice, my conscious choice, to have that kind of person in my life. My choice is about achieving happiness, not simple attention or melodrama or negativity. Does that mean I’m glorifying what I do, ignoring possible negative consequences? No, I don’t think so. Whether or not it’s obvious from this blog, I’m an analytical person. I weigh pros and cons of almost every decision (almost — there are moments when I’m completely spontaneous, thank goodness)… both for myself and for others. I’m all about risk management. Friends probably read that in much of what I write. Others… it doesn’t matter. If what I write is just entertaining, that’s good, too. That’s what I hoped for.

I write most often about the positive outcomes that have proceeded from my choices, at least some of them. I write about them because they are more important to me than the negatives, the barriers, the crises. If the bad things that happen, or that could happen, were my focus, I would write about those. No, actually, I wouldn’t write at all.

I choose personal happiness. Sure that’s selfish, even when it’s a considered choice. Is it less selfish to choose constant misery, guilt, snarling, backstabbing and masochism?  I don’t know… in my opinion, that path is not only negative, but lazy and narrow.

Look… I’m not asking here for yet another discussion of adultery or infidelity, and whether there is ever any justification for it. That’s been done elsewhere, and done well. It’s always going to come down to personal choice, and the hope that others respect that, at the very least, I’m making decisions based on information they are not privy to, decisions that I’ve put more time into than they know;  I will give those others that same consideration and respect. And I will always hope that they, too, will choose happiness, whatever that means to them.


Responses

  1. Thank you for writing such a refreshing piece on what is an extremely difficult subject. Your argument is not only logical but rationale and and as you correctly note, `this is about personal choice and risk management.` In many respects, it is those that are guilty of the `crime` that often have to carry the burden of guilt. If we were perfectly satisfied with all we have have and we were secure enough within ourselves, then we would not be straying from the path in the first place… But this is not the case and hence we stray, but always live with the fear that we may be found out… and may cause damage that may often be irreparable.

    Thank you again.

  2. Thank you for this thoughtful and eloquent post. So often, within the world of blogging, what little we share is taken to represent the whole. I always appreciate posts that seek to untangle some of our private reasonings, while yet remaining discreet.

  3. I’m glad you set some things straight. No one really understands unless they’re in that position. As long as you’re happy, lady!

  4. Very well put. I know I’ve been guilty of glorifying these affairs and showing a cavalier attitude, but in truth it’s so much deeper than that. I was about to explain my reasons but decided not to post them, but now you’ve convinced me I should. It’s tough. The timing of you writing this is perfect.

  5. I’ll echo what everyone else has already said. We all rationalise our choices about everything we do, and accept that there are some things we can bear to live without, and some that are worth the consequences.

    Blogs are deceptive, in that there is much that happens behind the scenes, however soul-bearing they appear, and also because, despite their public exposure, they also often function as journals and outlets for what cannot be expressed elsewhere. We all have written posts that are designed to entertain, and those that that are simply outpourings of emotion. The difficulty in the latter case can be that one moment in time is then forever preserved in bloggy aspic, and adds to the over all picture.

    Ahem. I seem to have completely got off the point here. Great post, honey.

  6. As you’ll be aware, I’m one of the people who wrote on this subject. I was very, very careful to try to disassociate my discussion from any moral or ethical stance, even whilst recognising that the position one takes will always be informed by ones own moreal position.

    Or will it?

    One thing I believe is that we may recognise that we have made choices that may not, in any absolute sense, be ideal but that we also accept that life is rarely ideal either. We do what we do in pursuit of … something, that something varying from person to person. You’ve made choices that fit your overall philosophy of life and I certainly cannot criticise you for that.

    Hell, I’ve made enough “mistakes” and navigated enough difficult terrain (with variable degrees of success) – it’s hard for me, then, to take any kind of moral high ground over the way that others choose to live. I just hope your choices continue, on the whole, to make you happy :)

  7. If we’re in an exclusive relationship, epecially one that’s long-term, perhaps one of the reasons one –or both–of us may considering “straying” is if our sex lives become boring and predictable. I love spaghetti, but I wouldn’t want to have it every day for the rest of my life! And that’s no reflection of the quality of the particular spaghetti in question. I think it’s really essential to keep some “spice” in a monogamous relationship, or chances are that it won’t be monogamous for long. That’s just human nature, and not a reflection on anyone’s character as a person. There are lots of ways to keep a relationship spicy, interesting, unpredictable, and intimate.

  8. You’re right. There are no one-size-fit-all answers. We each have to do what is right for us, at a certain point in time. Live and let live.

    Great post.

  9. Damocles, you make an excellent point about the fact that there are already problems existing as evidenced by the decision to look and play elsewhere. The whole thing is imperfect and rife with risk, so the fact that we choose it at all says something.

    Beth, that’s a difficult line to walk… between honesty and ‘none of your business’. :)

    Elizabeth — I’m happier more of the time now (sometimes ecstatic) than I was before. I think that’s worth something.

    Stratocast, if you do decide to write about it, I’ll be very interested in reading it. We all tend to treat sex cavalierly in our writing… I think it’s a natural wish to show the best of what is happening, at least some of the time.

    Z, you’re very wise to recognize that even the posts that seem the most revealing are only revealing of one moment in time. And for me… I can’t seem to feel consistently from one moment to the next, so it doesn’t always reveal much at all.

    Ro — I think that’s the issue sometimes… the fact that life isn’t ideal, nor is it black / white. We can’t know what another person deals with, either logistically, or emotionally, or mentally, based on past experiences. And sometimes the right combination of mistakes can produce acceptable results.

    Vienna — You are absolutely right that two people can solve an awful lot of issues by being willing to shake things up. And one person has to be willing to make the first move, certainly. It does eventually take willingness and desire to improve things from both partners, though. I’m eternally jealous of those who can work together in that way.

  10. i’ve been in some um… curious situations in my life as far as relationships go. so when i find myself getting all moralistic about what someone else is doing, i try to remember to say to myself “who are YOU to judge?” it doesn’t always work, but it helps to maintain perspective.

    Z, your second paragraph on blogs may be off point, but it is perfect nevertheless.

  11. Strikes me that, like people who object to porn, if you don’t want to read blogs about infidelity, don’t visit them…. :)

  12. Big Daddy — I know ‘live and let live’ aren’t just words for you. Thanks for your kind words.

    OG — It’s back to the idea of glass houses, right?

    Mendicatus — I think we should have t-shirts made. “Don’t like it? Don’t read it.”

  13. I’ve got a post called ‘feedback’ on my blog which, on the one hand, feels a little snarky, even to me, and yet, when you get judgmental emails/comments … so I wrote: “If you don’t like what you read here, go elsewhere. Life is too short: don’t waste your time — you won’t get it back.”

  14. Obviously I hold no judgment on those involved with infidelity, but I could not have said that a year ago. Everyone makes choices, and you’re right, those are very personal and no one else’s business. Nor are those choices open for judgment by anyone other than the one making them.

    Like you, I tend to analyze things. I seek out all the risks before plunging in, weighing each against it’s possible outcome. Perhaps it’s an Aries thing, always strategizing, but so much better to work with as big a picture as you can. Some choices are easier than others. Some risks are worse than others. But in the end, if I cannot choose for myself, than what was the point?

  15. Beth — You know, sometimes you have to be snarky to get your point across. It never ceases to amaze me that people insist on reading blogs that they find offensive.

    Akrazael — We change based on our experiences and what we know, right? A few years ago, I had very fixed opinions about adultery, too. I was also miserable. Sometimes compromise (and risk management, obviously) is the name of the game.

  16. Miss Marianne,
    I have learnt through life’s lessons, that above all, nothing is ever black and white.

    In my experience, and through many discussions, I have come to the conclusion that people cheat for 2 reasons:

    1) A lack of respect for a person or boundary placed, consciously or otherwise.
    2) A craving for intimacy.

    You’ll receive no judgment from me on either side. But I do understand the craving for intimacy on a more personal note. This idea of finding the perfect person, getting married, knocking out 3.4 kids, and then retiring happily whilst whittling wood on the front porch together, is well, complete and utter propagandistic bullshit.

    Enough said.

  17. Secretary, you have a very good point about how unrealistic that suburban dream is. In my ideal world (at least how I view it right this minute), one would be able to establish one or two anchor relationships, and have meaningful experiences and encounters outside of those relationships as desired, and with the consent and maybe participation of the anchor partners. Perhaps that is idealistic, but it would also seem more realistic than two people going off into the sunset together, ignoring changes in situation and each other.

    As for the two reasons you listed for infidelity? Hmmm. I guess I would use them more as broad categories, with many variations and individual circumstances within each.

  18. Yes, those 2 I mentioned are very broad. For good reason too. ;) It goes back to the first line of my original comment. So much room for spectrum….

  19. Marianne, today is the day I wrote about it. Not my most eloquent post ever, but it’s done.

  20. Thanks for tackling a difficult subject, Marianne. Great, insightful, honest and yummy as always. Hugs.

  21. Good point, NS.

    Stratocast — I went and read. Will be commenting soon. Thank you for being so brave to write about it.

    Gillette — Thank you for your sweetness, and for helping inspire me to write this.

  22. Marianne, the truth is you seem so much more balanced and thoughtful than many people I know who would never engage in extramarital activities and who would judge others harshly for doing so. You are welcome evidence that human beings and human actions are not nearly as simple as moralists would like to believe. I’m so grateful for human complexity!

  23. This is such a lovely comment, Katie. Thank you for your vote of confidence… I feel truly touched.


Leave a response

Your response:

Categories