He seemed very nice… floral language, keen insights, husky, low, lightly accented voice, full lips, gentle dark eyes. No, he seemed more than nice. He seemed… perfect. Our first conversations were playful, sparkling, witty. He wanted me from the first moment… there was never any hesitation. I was flattered, so flattered, by his attention, by his almost constant desire to have my attention, online, on the phone… whatever I would give him.
Gradually, though, that continued, single-minded focus became too much. I began to feel that he wasn’t hearing what I was saying. He disregarded my need to do other things, talk to other people, keep my life afloat under the barrage of his attention.
So, I ended it. I understood that if he didn’t listen to me then, he certainly wouldn’t later, when we might engage in a physical relationship.
***********
No. That’s not how it happened. Yes, the warning signs were there, but I ignored them. I rolled my eyes a little, and thought how sweetly annoying it was that he wanted me so badly that he chose to gently bulldoze me. He asked over and over again for an early meeting, before I really felt certain that I wanted to meet him just as badly. I talked myself into it. There was a convenient opportunity approaching. Why not? He was nice to me, attractive, passionate. What was the risk, really?
So, I met him. I told him where I would be staying, but I also insisted that we meet in the lobby of my hotel. He agreed, reluctantly, as though he couldn’t understand my hesitation. Neither could I, really.
I was seated in an armchair, nervously perusing every man who came into the lobby. When he walked in, I was surprised. He was older, obviously, than he had told me, and considerably shorter. Neither of those two factors made him physically unattractive — quite the opposite. But I knew immediately that a man who hid the truth from me now was likely to continue to do so.
I stood and greeted him, then we sat side by side on a sofa, and chatted briefly. He came almost straight to the point, and asked if he could come up to my room. I declined politely, and said I didn’t think it would work out.
**********
Damn. You knew it this time, didn’t you. That’s not what I said to him.
I hesitated. I convinced myself that a little white lie about his appearance was hardly enough to condemn him. And he’d driven all this way to meet me. He obviously wanted me. I was still flattered.
I nodded, stood, led him to the elevator. We didn’t talk on the way up, we didn’t touch. He watched me speculatively the whole way. Once in the room, I moved to the mini-fridge, wanting to offer him water or a glass of wine. He grabbed my shoulders from behind, turned me to him, and spoke.
“You are so very beautiful. You are perfect.”
I remembered then my initial feelings of attraction to his soft, seductive voice, and I began to melt into him as he kissed me. The kiss didn’t last though. He backed me to the bed, and pushed me, roughly, onto it, on my back, then pinned my shoulders with his hands, and straddled my waist. I looked into his eyes, and saw something I hadn’t expected. I saw desire, yes… no, not really desire. I saw cold, naked lust. He moved one hand to my blouse and began to pull at the top button. I felt suddenly powerless. I realized that I was afraid of this man.
“Wait. Please. You’re moving too quickly.”
“You know you want this.”
“No, I don’t know that. Stop. Now. It’s time for you to go.” And, with barely suppressed rage in check, he did.
**********
Obviously, it didn’t happen that way. I felt an obligation. I invited this man into my life, into my bed. How could it hurt to follow through? Perhaps I was being overly sensitive.
He pulled my clothes off of me, and off of himself, and, with his full weight on me, began to move his stiff member into position. I did stop him there… I told him that I needed to freshen up, and that while I was gone, he needed to put on a condom. I handed him the box I had conveniently placed on the bedside table. Condom use was something we had negotiated in advance. It was no surprise.
When I returned naked to the bed, he grabbed me and pulled me onto it, and began to manoeuvre into position again. My own arousal was heightened, but even then, I knew something was off. I reached down to him, and realized that he hadn’t, in fact, sheathed himself.
“You’re not getting inside me without a condom.”
“Yeah, fine, okay.”
He was clearly displeased, but we fucked then… quickly, impatiently, but at least with the protection on which I had insisted. He was skilled, moved in all the right ways, found all the right buttons to press, brought me to more than one rushed but volcanic orgasm.
And when we were both sated, I sent him on his way, knowing that I couldn’t deal with his level of selfishness and deception.
**********
Except that I didn’t.
Fuck. This is the part that’s hard.
He stayed. We fucked again. And again. And each time, I came, and each time, he tried to fool me, to get away with going bareback, despite my insistence otherwise. And then, finally, while I tried to sleep and block out the full understanding of how he was treating me, hoping he would just fucking leave, he mounted me one last time, and didn’t wait for my acquiescence. When I tried to pull away, yelled no at him, he held me down, told me that he wouldn’t take long. He pushed inside me, his bare cock inside my vulnerable cunt, pinned me with his weight, stared at me with his cold, dead eyes while I tried to turn away and disappear inside myself. He thrust roughly, over and over, while the tears ran down my face. This time I didn’t come. This time, I was horrified and guilt-ridden and full of disgust. With every thrust, I felt the risk I had taken, was taking, and how I was being punished for my arrogance and weakness.
When he had finished, when he had filled me with his disgusting self, he rolled off of me, got out of the bed, dressed, then bent to me, and kissed my forehead. He seemed oblivious to my tears and the way my body was curled protectively into a ball.
“Goodbye, darling. That was wonderful. I can’t wait to see you again.”
“Get the hell out, you bastard.”
**********
No. That’s not what I said.
“Of course. Goodbye.”
Then I got out of bed, scrubbed myself clean in the hottest of showers, walked in a daze to my computer, went online to block him. Somehow, I didn’t quite manage to block his memory, or my shame.



Like car crash tv. I was reading it through my fingers. A horrible experience but so powerful and well told. Fabulous writing… and Ruf thought so too x
By: havingmycake on June 28, 2008
at 1:27 pm
Oh, sweetheart.
The shame, what is with the fucking shame?? I say this, not to you, hon, but to myself. I want to whisper I could have written this
Whisper it, so no-one will know. So no-one will know how stupid, stupid I was, before I learned how to say no. Before I learned to cherish myself. It was not a thing anyone else ever taught me. And yet, his role was deeply, profoundly shameful. And I wonder. After, do they feel shame? Or would they find our feelings utterly inexplicable?
By: Beth on June 28, 2008
at 1:27 pm
This is beautifully written, Marianne… but I wished so badly that what I was reading was fictional.
By: Lakey on June 28, 2008
at 1:57 pm
I’d fucking kick him in the balls if I could for you, my lady.
Or wait, let me revise: I’d give him a backhanded slap so powerful it would send him reeling…
Oh no, I actually think a heel to the scrotum fits your final revision best.
And then I’d remove it to beat him to a bloody pulp.
Yeah, that’s better.
By: naughtysecretary on June 28, 2008
at 3:07 pm
Oh, my…hugs to you, My Dear One.
By: gillette on June 28, 2008
at 3:44 pm
Powerfully written. It is the reason why I do not meet the guys I met on Ashley Madison. I know myself too well – I would easily go down that path.
I too was hoping it was fiction.
By: Kyra on June 28, 2008
at 7:16 pm
I’m shivering here even though it’s a zillion degrees.
By: seraglioletters on June 28, 2008
at 7:18 pm
Cake and Ruf — Thank you, and thanks for reading it first and giving me the thumbs up. You guys are terrific. x
Beth — Thank you for the empathy. To answer your question, I’m sure they’d be shocked to know it even bothered us. Because they’re clueless.
Lakey — Not fictional. Also not something I think about frequently. It happened over a year ago. And this morning, I woke up and knew immediately that it was time to write about it. Weird.
NS — You are a great person to have on one’s side. I wish I could translate more of my guilt into anger sometimes.
Gillette — Thank you. Hug appreciated.
Kyra — I guess I at least need to say that I’ve met relatively few men that I knew online first… well, more than a few, but less than many. And only one went like that. One or two others were less than positive, but not in that way. The majority have been good guys who were looking for the same kind of connection I was. Thanks for the kind words.
Seraglio — I know exactly what you mean.
By: Marianne on June 28, 2008
at 7:35 pm
This is a remarkable piece of writing, and also a remarkable insight into how we retell ourselves our own stories until we can arrive at a version we can live with.
I wish this hadn’t happened to you.
By: Inconnu on June 28, 2008
at 11:02 pm
What fucking scum! What a piece of shit excuse for a human being. Wait, I take that back – humans, real humans, don’t do that to other humans.
He is an animal.
Marianne – I am so sorry this happened to you. You have all my love and support.
Unconditionally,
Alex
By: Alex on June 28, 2008
at 11:41 pm
I was talking about situations much like this one to a friend only the other day. I think there is a tendancy for women to automatically default to politeness and override their internal alarm system. Bad situations can sometimes occur simply because we don’t want to appear rude, or hurt someone’s feelings. It is why my advice is always, always trust your instincts. They are your survival mechanism, after all.
You have no cause to feel shame over this encounter. The guilt is entirely his.
This was a brave and honest post and, for what it is worth, you have my sympathy and respect.
By: Luka on June 29, 2008
at 3:02 am
Each time I read the revision, I felt with more and more certainty what was approaching. Each time I hoped it wouldn’t be. But there it was, bold as brass at the end, the reason I fear my own lust and feel disgust at what men can become.
I’m glad you’re able to write about and, and hope you can understand that you still hold the power – he took nothing from you, and gave you the strength to know, next time, where to draw the line.
This is a dangerous game we all play, a cocktail of lies, deceipt and secrets, to others and to ourselves. I’m pleased you were able to take an experience so awful, and turn it into what is easily one of the most deep and emotional (and, in a twisted way, beautiful) blog-posts I’ve ever read.
More strength to you. x
By: Mendicatus on June 29, 2008
at 5:09 am
Why is it that by accepting responsibilities for our actions, we somehow feel compelled to take responsibility for others’, too? We take on the shame and the guilt because we don’t want to admit that we have lost control of the situation, because at that point we secretly, selectively believe what we internalised as young girls – that we can lead men on to behave like animals.
Kisses
By: Z on June 29, 2008
at 7:54 am
brilliantly written. i’m just sorry that it’s real. but i never doubted that it was. and the way you presented it made it even more powerful – all those missed chances to take the other fork.
it is so hard to believe that someone might violate our trust. and so hard not to blame ourselves.
this one will stay with me for a long time…
By: oatmeal girl on June 29, 2008
at 10:44 am
There are some men – women too, probably – who seem to get a kick out of imposing their desires on people who just don’t want to play in the same way. OK, sometimes the signals might get confused, but you had spent some time communicating what you wanted beforehand. And when push came to shove, he ignored.
I suppose a rule of thumb is that if you find someone who isn’t immediately turned off when you make it clear you don’t like what’s happening, you just get up, get dressed and walk away. Don’t even waste your breath saying goodbye. Of course, we all need to get that wrong before we know how to get it right.
By: Duke Orsino on June 29, 2008
at 10:56 am
What a scumbag. Have you thought of mentioning the police to him? Nothing would come of it of course but it might give him a scare and make him pause for thought for his next time. A trip to the doc might be in order too, sadly, if he is a fan of bareback sex.
Take care and be more careful.
Brian
By: Brian on June 29, 2008
at 4:07 pm
Inconnu — Thank you for your support, as always. So true about the retelling of stories. This was tough to write, because I did try to cut through some of the crap I told myself about it. Even now, I don’t know how successful I was.
Alex — Thank you for your support, as well. I’m really fine… it happened over a year ago. I just wasn’t ready to write about it until now. Weird.
Luka — So right about listening to your instincts. Your kindness is appreciated.
Mendicatus — What an incredibly kind comment. Thank you. Neither you, nor any man, should never feel that kind of responsibility for what one idiot did, in my opinion. You know in your heart what you are and aren’t capable of, or at least what you would or would not do. That’s all you can be responsible for. xo
Z — That’s exactly right. Whatever I tell myself intellectually, with that rational part of my brain, there’s still part of me that says that nothing he did was out of line, that I was completely at fault, the reason he was there, it was up to me to control the situation and his behaviour. Argh. The things we implant in the minds of our girl children.
Oatmeal Girl — Thank you for your kindness, too. The story is true, but happened so many months ago that I feel almost guilty for bringing to anyone’s attention now, and getting all this sympathy and support… aack… there’s that guilt thing again. Seems to be built in to us.
Duke O — It was such a confusing time. I knew he was doing the wrong thing, I knew that I had made my condom expectations clear over and over. On the other hand, there was arousal, and I had allowed him in my bed. And yes… of course I should have walked away (or made him). And yes… we are all prone to making that kind of mistake. C’est la vie.
Brian — At the time, I just wanted to be held and told that I wasn’t a bad person for allowing it to happen. I talked to a number of people, and got the support I needed, for the most part. I had no desire to talk to him in any way, even to scare him. Even picturing him while I was writing this post brought back all sorts of horrible feelings. The whole time I was writing, there was this nasty feeling in the pit of my stomach. I had to detach myself emotionally in order to finish. Anyhow, point is, it was all over with many months ago. And yes, I did get myself tested a few months after, and all is well. Thanks for your kind thoughts.
By: Marianne on June 29, 2008
at 4:21 pm
Wow. I’m stunned. Such naked honesty. Thank you for writing this. It’s not only a warning to all of us who play with others, but a frank assessment of the risks in this world of ours.
By: tom paine on June 30, 2008
at 9:12 am
It’s so easy to get wrapped up in the shame of bad decisions; but we’ve all made them. Reading this, I want to hold you, stroke your hair, and remind you how incredible you truly are. This had to have been one of the toughest posts you’ve ever written, but weakness does not prevail in your words. What an incredible, beautiful woman you are to hold up your mirror – not just for yourself, but for every other person who has experienced the gut-wrenching theft of that which should be given freely.
Today you are a hero.
By: Akrazael on June 30, 2008
at 9:12 am
Tom — Thank you for your kind words. There are definitely risks. All we can do is try to manage them and listen to our inner voice, right?
Akrazael — What a sweet person you are. I could use some hair stroking.
And you’ve done a wonderful job of the ego-stroking, too. xo
By: Marianne on June 30, 2008
at 11:20 am
Hey, just emailed you on the address I always used to use, not emailed you in ages though so not sure if it’s the right one. I’m really fucking angry. You’ve nothing to be ashamed of, by the way. Not arrogant or weak, you’ve done nothing wrong at all. xxxx
By: Caroline on June 30, 2008
at 5:08 pm
Thanks, Caroline, my sweet. Your email and your comment are both appreciated, as is your anger on my behalf. All is well, though… no worries. xo
By: Marianne on June 30, 2008
at 8:23 pm
So, this is the second time I read this because I couldn’t believe that I read it right the first time.
Hun, I don’t know if anyone has posted this here yet but you have been raped!
In my book, no means no and this was clearly against your will. I don’t know if you have enough to press charges or move forward with it but I will say that it is what it is.
I am sorry this happened to you. It shouldn’t have happened. I do hope you find support and help. That guy is an asshole and is what gives us guys a bad name.
I am just hoping that you are OK….
Flyinfox_SATX
By: Flyinfox_SATX on July 1, 2008
at 12:16 pm
Fox — It’s okay, my chivalrous friend. It happened over a year ago. I am definitely okay. I had the time and support I needed… I still have some work to do to stop feeling guilty, but all is well. He doesn’t give you guys a bad name… really. I see him as one selfish and cold individual, not as a representative of anything. Thank you for being sweet.
By: Marianne on July 1, 2008
at 12:22 pm
Powerful post. I think it’ll help me in the future. The road less taken.
aoefe
By: aoefe on July 1, 2008
at 5:30 pm
aoefe — If it helps, I’m very happy. Thanks for commenting.
By: Marianne on July 1, 2008
at 6:38 pm
Rape.
I hope he dies of AIDS. He’d deserve it.
By: M on July 1, 2008
at 7:25 pm
I know, sweetie. I know.
By: Marianne on July 1, 2008
at 8:40 pm
And you have nothing to be ashamed of.
Hugs…
By: M on July 1, 2008
at 10:38 pm
You still amaze me with the raw emotion that you can conjure with text.
What this man did was unforgivable, You have no reason to be ashamed, he does. The thoughtless arrogance only prove that he is a prick.
The pain of misplaced trust is sometimes very difficult to bear. That is why there are those of us here (and there) who care a great deal for you. Thank you for sharing this painful memory and baring a part of your soul to us your faithful readership. You are truly beautiful.
By: Chexmate on July 2, 2008
at 8:14 am
Such powerful writing. And you have captured the self-doubt and frustration of ‘if only’s that can only come with hindsight. I suppose that is the error of being human – we tell ourselves to trust people even when inside our doubts tell us otherwise.
I am so sorry that you had to endure such a monster.
Cate xxx
By: Cate on July 2, 2008
at 9:04 am
I echo the outrage of the others…this guy is a dirtbag supreme! This was a complete violation of your trust. He deserves a special place in hell!
your dignity and ablility to write about this amazes me…you’re a classy lady.
dickie
By: dickie on July 2, 2008
at 12:28 pm
Thank you for sharing this, Marianne. I’m thinking hugs your way – for lack of anything else I can do. I really don’t know what else to say.
xx Dee
By: Curvaceous Dee on July 2, 2008
at 10:21 pm
I remember hearing about this first-hand from you. At the time i sympathized and comforted you — as I would like to do again now.
As far as the piece itself is concerned, i think you managed to write about a very traumatic situation extremely effectively. Kudos to you on the clear-headed way in which you approached the subject. I know it cannot have been easy for you, which makes me want to send double the amount of support.
You clearly aportion a great deal of blame to yourself, and i want to reiterate what i said back then: it was NOT your fault. You are NOT to blame. You are the survivor — he was the perpetrayer. It was his crime, his repulsive actions.
I truly hope that by writing this you’ve managed to achieve a proper level of closure.
Much love,
Juno (that was) x
By: Juno That Was on July 6, 2008
at 3:29 am
Aww, lovey a warm squeeze….
Just what you never want to hear anyone write about.
And so humbly honest about the way we rephrase, and relive how we wish it could have gone- all the alternate scenarios.
Where we shredded them,
where we violated them in their own most vulnerable and irreparable of places,
….where we never lived it in the first place
but then it is lived, it is known… I don’t know why….
but I echo with Juno, I hope the act of writing it out has brought a closure or a more removed viewpoint.
and maybe some form of ‘attenzione’ for all of us.
xxxxx sabine
By: Sabine on July 7, 2008
at 7:58 am
M — Thank you. I appreciate your hugs.
Chex — You’ve brought tears to my eyes. Thank you, my friend.
Cate — Thank you for your understanding. Hindsight can be a real bitch.
Dickie — I blush. Thank you.
Dee — Hugs are exactly right. Thank you.
Juno — Your support was appreciated then, and it’s appreciated now. It’s so easy to understand on an intellectual level that he was just a jerk… it’s so much more difficult to process it emotionally. And yes, I think that finally being ready to write about it was important to the process of closure.
Sabine — Writing about it was interesting… I felt so detached, like I was watching what happened, which enabled me to imagine the alternatives. Very interesting. Closure? Hope so. I think so. Thank you, honey.
By: Marianne on July 7, 2008
at 5:32 pm
This is so heart-breaking to read. I am sorry this happened to you. It was not your fault.
By: Ellie on July 8, 2008
at 10:13 am
That was awesome. Thanks for sharing this. I think all women find themselves wishing they’d asserted themselves sexually at one time or another.
No, you can’t change the past.
Yes, you can make another choice next time.
By: Desiree on July 8, 2008
at 2:21 pm
Ellie — Thank you. You are kind.
Desiree — Yes, it’s all about the present, and the choices we make now, definitely. Regrets really are pointless… although rather built in at times.
By: Marianne on July 8, 2008
at 2:59 pm
What a foul creature. Beautifully written though. x
By: Cheekydani on July 10, 2008
at 3:49 am
Thank, Dani, and thank you for visiting.
By: Marianne on July 10, 2008
at 8:28 am
I agree with Cheekydani: that man was vile, but you’re a truly good writer.
First time here, I’ll be back, for sure!
By: Kim on July 11, 2008
at 3:58 am
Kim — A true pleasure to have you here. Please do come back. I’m loving all over your blog… it’s great.
By: Marianne on July 11, 2008
at 9:27 am
I agree with Oatmeal Girl. You did a marvelous job of recounting it, and all the forks in the road that were present as you went that path.
I’m terribly sorry for what happened to you – it IS a warning to all of us.
I’ve done a couple drunken one-night stands and was fortunate that the person I had picked up, was willing to stop what he was doing when I said, this is enough. (if it hurt that bad in my drunken state, I can’t imagine what it would have felt like had i been sober – and one of my not so proud moments either)
By: Musns on July 13, 2008
at 11:57 am
Thank you for your support, Musns.
By: Marianne on July 13, 2008
at 6:39 pm
You aren’t the only one with an experience like this, but I’m sorry it’s one of the things we have in common, for both our sakes. I admire you being able to write about it as you go over your infidelity past.
By: kate on June 18, 2009
at 5:21 pm
I hate that anyone has had a similar experience, Kate, and I’m especially sorry you have.
By: Marianne on June 19, 2009
at 5:02 pm